Here are the 11 best near dupes or alternatives for Maybelline Tattoo Studio Smokey Gel Pencil.
The top picks based on ingredients are Too Faced Killer Liner 36 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil , Avon Fmg Cashmere 24 Hr Cream Eyeliner , Neutrogena Neutrogena® Intense Gel Eyeliner , etc. See the full list below.
If you are interested in finding near dupes for any product, you can also use our near dupe finder tool.
Note: We do not make any claims that the near dupes will work with the same or comparable efficacy as the original product. For certain products (like blushes, foundations, lipsticks, etc.), the near dupes shown may not be the right shade. We recommend swatching the product or referring to brand swatches to find the right shade.
50.0%
Match
46.15%
Match
41.67%
Match
37.04%
Match
35.9%
Match
35.29%
Match
34.48%
Match
33.33%
Match
32.26%
Match
32.26%
Match
32.0%
Match
© 2026 Beauty Master List, All Rights Reserved.